Banns out of proportion and possible system fixes/reworks

Hello, I have multiple complaints about the report/bann system which need to be adressed. I will try to describe the problem followed up by a solution. {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} First of all, banns/chat restriction for "verbal abuse" are completely out of propotion compared to other offenses such as Feeding, trolling or afking. There have been multiple Threads on this forum and on reddit about this and Riot doesnt seem to react. To make it easy to understand, lets imagine the following scenario which everyone playing rankeds on a regular basis has experienced multiple times. On the Toplane we have {{champion:92}}, jungle {{champion:421}}, midlane {{champion:61}}, adc {{champion:22}} and {{champion:63}} support. {{champion:92}} wins her matchup against {{champion:17}} easily and is 3-0 after 10 minutes, Jungle is also doing good and {{champion:61}} is 4-1. The game would be a free win if there wasnt that {{champion:63}} support which died to an invade at 1:30 minutes, followed up by a 2v2 double kill for the enemie {{champion:67}} after 5 minutes. The super aggro brand (Platin 5) decides to go ham 1 minutes after this with {{champion:22}} items being {{item:1055}} and {{item:1036}} and vayne having {{item:1055}} and {{item:1038}}. Every Supporter which is not Bronze 2-5 would know how %%%%%%ed it is to engage 2v2 with this much of an item disadvantage. However, {{champion:63}} decided to go full aggro because playing defensive is boring to him and its "_just a game_ and he wants to have fun". After {{champion:63}} died for the 5th time in 12 minutes, {{champion:61}} is already tilted of her botlane but decides to ask brand kindly to die less. [{{champion:61}}] (11:32) "**hey, I know that you had some unlucky plays at bot but please play defensive and let Riven and me carry you :)"** Eventhough {{champion:63}} did nothing all game long but to die and is 1-7-1 when laning phase ended, his team is still able to win because the rest of his team played well. However, our {{champion:63}} support doesn't care about warding or about doing anything usefull but keeps to splitpush the botlane or walk around in the enemie jungle doing nothing. He doesn't flame, he is just playing worse than every bronze 2 player. But when {{champion:63}} dies for no reason for the 13th time and the enemie therefore takes baron, {{champion:61}} which had a hard day at work loses her mind. {{champion:61}} (32:13) "You had ONE job, which was NOT to feed" {{champion:61}} (32:21) "F***ING BOOSTED ANIMALS in this elo" {{champion:61}} (32:30) "HOW MUCH WAS YOUR ELOBOOST?" {{champion:61}} (33:01) "DUMB IDIOT" {{champion:61}} played really well, didnt flame until the game was already lost and then raged at {{champion:63}} who obviously neither wanted to win not tried to do so. After the game {{champion:61}} got informed she was banned for 14 days, {{champion:63}} played another ranked which he lost againending up with a kda of 3-14-7 but didn't get banned. {{champion:63}} ruined the experience of 8 players in just 90 minutes because he played really bad and trolled. However he didn't run down mid with cleanse, 6 shoes in his inventory and a red scanner over his head and thus he can't be punished. {{champion:61}} was in full tryhard mode, played her best and just flamed one guy which was intentionally playing bad and deserved the flame. Also she didn't insulted {{champion:63}} as human (personally) but just as a bad summoner. No one gives a f**k about being called an idiot on the internet but still {{champion:61}} got banned. This scenario points out two main problems: 1. Some Banns/restrictions are nothing more but a bad joke, especially those for "verbal abuse". 2. Trolls/AFKS/Feeders do not get punished, until they make it really obvious so that even a freshborn ape could tell they are trolling/feeding/afkin intentionally. 3. Boosted people do not get banned because they have money and most likely also spend it on skins so riot doesnt touch these kids. Once I have had this ashe on my team (plat. 5) which didnt knew the basics of kiting and just autoattacked standing still in teamfights. I looked up her OP.gg telling me she had a 90% winrate on akali over 12 games with a 15 KDA and 10 games with 100% winrate on nidalee. She seemes to have picked those champs up for some games, play incredibly well on them and then just go back to her old adc mains and keep playing bad. Makes sense, doesnt it? Obviously not eloboosted. Kappa. **Solution** 1. Obviously it would make more sense to bann people which insult other players personally, being racistic or hompohobic. Nobody cares about being called "%%%%%%ed" or "idiot" on the internet. This is the speech of the internet... 2. Experienced players could review games of reported trolls and see if they were trolling or if their bad score is because they had to lane against a pantheon or a kayle/yi duoQ or something similar. There is a similar system in CS:GO and it works. Reviewers which decide wrong often dont get to review more cases and people with a high "review score" would have more voice. 3. If a player suddenly hides his IP when playing, plays differenct champs and has a huge winning streaks, often duoquing with other boosted accounts, its 99.999999999999999999% save this accounts got eloboosted so it should be permabanned no matter what. {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} {{item:3070}} One more stupid thing about the report system is, that it doesnt takes reports over games played but reports over time. X plays 50 games per week and gets reported in 2 out of these. Y plays 5 games per week with the same report rate. X will be get chat restricted or banned, Y wont get any punishment. Is this fair? Again, nice logic riot ;)
Share
Report as:
Offensive Spam Harassment Incorrect Board
Cancel